M.Zharkikh's personal site logo
Mail to site
Print version
News (RSS)
History / Monographs / Two traditions chronicles / "Belarusian" chronicle / Battle on the Vorskla river in

Two traditions chronicles
Grand Duchy of Lithuania

"Belarusian" chronicle

Battle on the Vorskla river in 1399

Nicholas Zharkikh

"Tale the Battle on the Vorskla river" in the "Belarusian" chronicle is derived from the S1LSI. Analysis of it very simple but instructive.

Versions text "Belarusian" chronicles

Versions text "Lithuanian" chronicles

Analysis versions

Conclusions

1. This tale in the "Belarusian" and "Lithuanian" chronicles entirely dependent on the Sophia 1st chronicles older recension and can not be any historical source. At separate essay dedicated to the history of the tale text, it will be shown that even the ancient text as part Bil0L severely damaged.

2. When copying the "Belarusian" and "Lithuanian" chronicles this story has continued to deteriorate, so I strongly recommend that historians use to study the text S1LSI rather than these chronicles. Especially characteristic appearance of a literary hero Promcheslov, which has spread to a number of copies.

3. The scribes of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania had no idea about the battle of the Vorskla river. All they knew about it borrowed from the Moscow chronicles.

Previous section | Table of content | Next section

Please this page? Help us to develop this site!

1978 2018 N.I.Zharkikh

Reprinting of articles from site are encouraged while
reference (hyperlink) to my site is provided

Site powered by

Load count : 78

Modified : 25.02.2018

If you look up the type error
on this page, please select it
by mouse and press Ctrl+Enter.